Top RCMP officer ‘very concerned’ over interference in N.S. shooting probe: inquiry

Chief Supt. Darren Campbell said it was crucial to keep details about the firearms under wraps as police investigated how the gunman obtained them

Article content

One of the top RCMP commanders handling Nova Scotia’s 2020 shooting rampage says he was “very concerned” that there might be political or other interference in the investigation of the case.

Advertisement 2

Article content

A day after the force’s commissioner Brenda Lucki denied there was any political meddling, Chief Supt. Darren Campbell told the inquiry into the killings Tuesday he stood by notes of a conference call with Lucki two years ago.

Those notes suggested the RCMP’s top boss had chastised local officers for not releasing details of the guns used by the shooter, and said she had promised the Liberal government the information would be divulged, tying the issue to new gun-control legislation about to be introduced.

Campbell testified that he has no idea what was said between Lucki and then Public Safety Minister Bill Blair or other members of the government, but had worries stemming from the call.

“I was very concerned because for me as a former team commander who understands the need to protect certain information so you could advance your investigation and hopefully meet your objectives … there was a very good reason we could not release those details,” he told the federal-provincial Mass Casualty Commission.

Advertisement 3

Article content

Campbell said it was important to keep information about the firearms under wraps as police investigated how the gunman obtained the weapons.

“We owed it to the victims, the survivors and their families to do our very best, to be able to meet those objectives,” he said. “Any interference, whether it be political or otherwise, that would have deterred us from properly investigating these offences and seeking justice the families deserved was unacceptable to me.

“Whatever that would be, whether it was political or not, I was very concerned that if it was political, if it was politically motivated, how the families would perceive that.”

Advertisement 4

Article content

As head of support services in the RCMP’s H division, Campbell oversaw the force’s critical-incident program in Nova Scotia during the spree, which saw two officers and 20 civilians killed by a man driving a replica police cruiser.

A hint of how the horrific incident has affected him and other officers came in the hearing’s final moments Tuesday. The 32-year veteran of the Mounties finished two days of mostly level-headed testimony on an emotional note, addressing the victims’ relatives directly.

“I apologize for failing,” he said while quietly sobbing on the witness stand. “I haven’t cried for two and a half years. I’m truly sorry that we failed you. I promise that we’ll do better.”

Campbell’s testimony had been hotly anticipated because of comments he made in his notes of the virtual meeting with Lucki 10 days after the mass shooting. The notes ignited charges of political interference in the investigation, though they did not come up during Monday’s questioning by commission counsel Rachel Young.

Advertisement 5

Article content

Campbell suggested that Lucki had criticized local officers for not releasing details on the killer’s guns, saying she had promised Blair the information would be divulged, with a Liberal gun-control bill about to be introduced.

Lucki appeared before a parliamentary committee Monday, saying that she did not urge the Nova Scotia officers to release the firearms information, and that no one in government pressured her to do so. She blamed the controversy on miscommunication.

In other testimony Tuesday, Campbell said he supported the decision to charge Lisa Banfield, the killer’s common-law wife, with supplying him ammunition.

We owed it to the victims, the survivors and their families to do our very best, to be able to meet those objectives

Chief Supt. Darren Campbell

Banfield’s case was eventually shifted into a restorative-justice program and on Tuesday she was discharged without a criminal record as she finished the program, amid evidence the woman was for years subject to harsh physical and emotional abuse by her spouse.

Advertisement 6

Article content

The chief superintendent said he and other top officers in the RCMP’s H division in Nova Scotia discussed the pros and cons of charging Banfield. It was clear there was sufficient evidence, so the issue was whether it was in the public interest, he said under questioning from James Lockyer, the woman’s lawyer.

“The optics were discussed,” said Campbell. “In terms of domestic violence victims, victim blaming — I thought that would be a significant issue … In terms of the victims’ families and what their expectations were or weren’t, how sympathetic they might be or not sympathetic to Lisa Banfield.”

In testimony to the inquiry Monday, Campbell highlighted at least two other areas where he clashed with superior officers at RCMP headquarters in Ottawa.

Advertisement 7

Article content

Campbell said he had repeatedly called for an independent police review of how the case was handled, only to be rebuffed by the force’s central command.

Headquarters seemed averse to having a police review of the situation when the Mass Casualty Commission was already under way, he said. But the officer said a review by outside critical-incident experts with no connection to those who led the RCMP effort in Nova Scotia could have recommended improvements long before the inquiry is completed.

Campbell also revealed Monday he thought it was important for the RCMP to continue releasing what information it could on the incident as time wore on, but headquarters told H division in late 2020 to no longer do so.

Lucki cancelled “at the last minute” tentative plans he had made to be interviewed by CBC’s Fifth Estate program that September, the inquiry heard.


  1. Style File: Beach-ready brights

    Hit the beach, lake, pool or backyard inflatable in style this summer season with one of these fashionable finds.

    Style File: Beach-ready brights
  2. Canadian drag queen superstar Kendall Gender talks Vancouver Pride

    Canada’s Drag Race finalist will be home in Vancouver to celebrate Vancouver Pride.

    Kendall Gender is the face of the Pride Collection from Canadian brand Annabelle Cosmetics.
  3. Advertisement 1

  4. Away luggage launches F.A.R technical line: Tried, tested and reviewed

    Ideal for day trips, festivals, exploration and around town

    F.A.R -- For All Routes
  5. Sun smarts: Sunscreen, UV-protective clothing are important elements for safeguarding skin

    It’s estimated that 9,000 Canadians will be diagnosed with melanoma skin cancer this year — 1,200 of whom will die.

    It's a good time to slather on some sunscreen.
  6. Beauty Bar: JVN Complete Instant Recovery Heat Protectant Leave-In Serum

    A nourishing leave-in hair serum promises to “repair and smooth” damaged, weak hair.

    JVN Complete Instant Recovery Heat Protectant Leave-In Serum.


Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.